Herman Krabbenhoft, an indefatigable baseball researcher and historical statistician, is renowned among members of the Society for American Baseball Research. In the fall 2024 Baseball Research Journal, he introduced what he hopes will be recognized as a mound equivalent of a batter hitting for the cycle — a single, double, triple and a homer in the same game. The hits need not be in order and in most cases are not.

His “Pitcher’s Cycle” requires “at least one player from each of the nine repeating batting slots (not necessarily in order) to be struck out: by one pitcher” in the game.
On Sept. 10, 2026, Jacob deGrom threw the ninth Pitcher’s Cycle of the season – in what Krabbenhoft now terms as a much rarer “Flawless Pitcher’s Cycle.”
A post I wrote in January 2026 and a subsequent email exchange between us helped inspire Dr. Krabbenhoft, a retired college professor, to create this higher level of achievement for pitchers. He introduced it in a presentation at the 2026 SABR annual convention in Cleveland.
Two Nationals pitchers benefit from this higher standard. In the first game of the 2025 season, MacKenzie Gore of the Nationals matched an opening day record set by Hall of Famer Bob Gibson in 1969: Gore struck out 13 batters in his six innings of work. He walked no one and didn’t give up a run.
That qualified, retrospectively, as a “Flawless Pitcher’s Cycle.” Gibson, however, failed to fan one of the batters he faced, so he didn’t make the list of Pitcher’s Cycles on that record-setting day. Gore became the 14th National to pitch a cycle. The most recent one before Gore was Max Scherzer in 2019. His was no. 400.
In Seattle, the Rangers’ deGrom not only struck out all nine batters at least once – he had 12 in six innings – but gave up just a single in recording 19 outs. The flawless cycle, defined by Krabbenhoft, requires a pitcher to allow no home runs; no base on balls and no hit-by-pitches.
The pitcher’s cycle was deGrom’s ninth in his MLB career. He’s tied with Scherzer, also with nine. The all-time leaders in career Pitchers’s Cycles are Randy Johnson with 21, Nolan Ryan 12 and Chris Sale 10.
Max and deGrom, with two flawless cycles each are in a five-way tie for third place behind The Big Unit and Sale, who have done it three times.
Sandy Koufax, Roger Clemens and Mashiro Tanaka also have two flawless cycles, according to Krabbenhoft’s exhaustive research.
With the massive increase in strikeouts in the past 25 years, however, standard Pitcher’s Cycles have become less rare. Seventy seasons passed before Tom Seaver became the 100th pitcher to achieve a cycle, but just 26 years for John Smoltz to pitch no. 200 in 1996. Fourteen years later, a 300th was pitched; nine years after that, no. 400. Now in the sixth season since then, Pitcher’s Cycle no. 500 was reached. (Krabbenhoft’s figures do not include the Negro Leagues recognized by MLB.)
The first “Flawless Pitcher’s Cycle” was achieved by Washington’s Hall of Famer Walter Johnson on Aug. 28, 1913, against the Red Sox, Johnson fanned everybody in the Sox batting order, didn’t walk or hit a batter and pitched 10 shutout innings before yielding an unearned run in the 11th and losing 1-0 – one of 26 times in his career that Johnson lost 1-0. After Bill James of the Red Sox pitched a flawless cycle the next season, some 21 years passed before another flawless cycle was achieved, Krabbenhoft found.
Over the next 50 years, just two more pitchers achieved flawlss cycles: Van Mungo of the Dodgers in September 1935 and Hal Newhouser of the Tigers at the tail-end of World War II. Then on on May 22, 1964, Juan Pizarro of the Chicago White beat the visiting Washington Senators, 3-1.
Sandy Koufax’s two flawless cycles in 1965 were the first of just three more through 1980. After a decade lull, such feats increased dramatically in the 1990s, along with the increase batters striking out.
Perhaps the prevalence of strikeouts will recede. Pitchers no longer have to bat in either league. The strike zone has been reduced before. Otherwise, the Krabbenhoft basic Pitcher’s Cycle might seem less of an achievement.
As Krabbenhoft wrote in Baseball Research Journal, “Pitcher’s Cycles have become more frequent than Batter’s Cycles, perhaps dimming the luster of the PC.” In recognizing this, he also made note that an outstanding performance such as Scherzer’s 20 strikeout game in 2016 did not qualify for the list because he didn’t fan the Tigers’ Victor Martinez.
Still, the flawless cycle, which some of today’s starters have accomplished in as few as six innings, is likely to remain a special achievement.
